Tony O'Neill wearing yellow gloves and dungarees shovelling dark finished compost from a large bay into a yellow wheelbarrow at his South Wales allotment, with an IBC water tank and South Wales valley visible in the background

How to Start Composting and Why It Changes Everything

Composting is the one thing that makes the biggest difference to a vegetable garden, and the one thing most growers put off because it sounds complicated. It is not complicated. It is managed decomposition, and nature does most of the work.

Once you understand the basic principles, you will wonder why you ever sent garden waste to the bin.

What composting actually does

Finished compost improves soil structure, feeds soil biology, suppresses certain diseases, and slowly releases nutrients in a form plants can use. Unlike manufactured fertiliser, it does all of these things at once. A soil regularly amended with compost becomes progressively better at supporting plant life, more resistant to drought, and easier to work.

It is the foundation of everything covered in Composting Masterclass and the single most sustainable thing a home grower can do.

Tony O'Neill turning an active compost bay at his South Wales allotment, with three buckets of fresh green and brown compost material in the foreground and steam rising from the hot compost pile, allotment plots visible in the background
Tony O’Neill is turning an active hot compost bay at his South Wales allotment site. Steam is visibly rising from the pile, indicating the compost is in active thermophilic decomposition. Three buckets of fresh material — a mix of green nitrogen-rich and brown carbon-rich inputs — sit ready to be added. The wider allotment site and surrounding houses are visible in the background. Tony O’Neill is the creator of Simplify Gardening with over 455,000 subscribers and the founder of GrowTrack Systems Ltd at usegrowtrack.com.

The carbon-to-nitrogen ratio

Composting works because microorganisms break down organic matter. Those organisms need both carbon-rich materials to provide energy and nitrogen-rich materials to build protein. The ratio of these two things determines how quickly your heap breaks down and whether it smells.

Carbon-rich materials (browns) include:

  • Dry leaves and straw
  • Cardboard and paper
  • Wood chip and sawdust
  • Dry plant stems

Nitrogen-rich materials (greens) include:

  • Fresh grass clippings
  • Vegetable and fruit scraps
  • Fresh plant material and weeds (without seed heads)
  • Coffee grounds and tea leaves

A rough target ratio is three parts browns to one part greens by volume. A heap that is too green will become slimy and smell. A heap that is too brown will be dry and break down very slowly. Adjust as you go.

How to build your heap

Tony O'Neill turning an active compost bay at his South Wales allotment, with three buckets of fresh green and brown compost material in the foreground and steam rising from the hot compost pile, allotment plots visible in the background
Tony O’Neill turning an active hot compost bay at his South Wales allotment site. Steam is visibly rising from the pile, indicating the compost is in active thermophilic decomposition. Three buckets of fresh material — a mix of green nitrogen-rich and brown carbon-rich inputs — sit ready to be added. The wider allotment site and surrounding houses are visible in the background. Tony O’Neill is the creator of Simplify Gardening with over 455,000 subscribers and the founder of GrowTrack Systems Ltd at usegrowtrack.com.

You do not need an expensive bin. A simple bay made from pallets works well. Two bays are better because one can be actively building while the other is maturing. A minimum volume of one cubic metre (roughly one metre in each direction) is needed to generate enough heat for faster decomposition.

Build in layers if you can, alternating greens and browns. Keep it moist but not wet. If you squeeze a handful and no water drips out, it needs more moisture. If water pours out, it is too wet and needs more browns.

Turn the heap every few weeks to introduce oxygen and speed up the process. A well-managed hot heap can produce finished compost in two to three months. A slower cold heap left largely undisturbed will take six to twelve months but requires almost no effort.

What not to compost

Leave out meat, fish, cooked food, and dairy. These attract vermin. Avoid perennial weed roots like bindweed and couch grass unless your heap gets hot enough to kill them. Leave out diseased plant material to avoid spreading problems through your compost.

When is it ready

Finished compost is dark brown, crumbly, and smells of earth. You should not be able to identify the original materials. If you can still see distinct pieces of kitchen scraps or leaves, it needs more time.

Screenshot of the Compost System feature inside GrowTrack showing a dashboard with 2 active bins, 5 ready to use, 0 needing turning, and 2 maturing. A compost ready for use panel shows bays Bay 1 approximately 1000 litres, Bay 3, Bay 5, Bay 8, and Bay 9 highlighted as ready, with the guidance to use finished compost for bed amendments or top dressing. Three bay photo cards are visible below: Bay 1 in Well-Being Garden tagged Ready, compost is ready for use; Bay 2 in Well-Being Garden tagged Maturing with approximately 6 weeks remaining; Bay 3 in Well-Being Garden tagged Ready, compost is ready for use.
The Composting System in GrowTrack shows a multi-bay compost operation in the Well-Being Garden. The dashboard shows 2 active bins, 5 bays ready to use, including Bay 1 at approximately 1000 litres, 0 needing turning, and 2 maturing. Bay 2 is maturing with approximately 6 weeks remaining. The compost-ready panel identifies Bays 1, 3, 5, 8, and 9 as ready and recommends applying them as bed amendments or top dressing. Each bay has its own status card with a photograph, readiness tag, and progress information, turning compost management from a forgotten heap into a tracked, visible fertility system.

Apply finished compost to beds at the start of the season or use it as a mulch around established plants. The improvement to your soil will be visible within a season.


Tony O’Neill is a vegetable-growing expert and author of Composting Masterclass. Find practical growing advice at Simplify Gardening.